Community, Diversity, Sustainability and other Overused Words

Earthquake Causes Collapse of 40 Story Building in Bangkok, Thailand.

The collapse of the high-rise building in Bangkok was directly tied to the 7.7-magnitude earthquake that originated in Myanmar

A 7.7 earthquake struck Myanmar and Thailand today, destroying a number of building and killing hundreds of people. Hundreds of km from the epicenter, a 40 story building in Bangkok Thailand collapsed, burying many of the 400 men working on the project.

1. Overview of the Earthquake and Building Collapse

On March 28, 2025, a 7.7-magnitude earthquake struck Myanmar, causing widespread damage in Myanmar and affecting neighboring Thailand. According to the web search results:

Myanmar Impact: At least 144 people were killed in Myanmar, with over 700 injured, as reported by the country's military junta leader, Min Aung Hlaing (web ID: 1). The quake damaged buildings in Naypyidaw, Mandalay, and the Sagaing region, including the former royal palace in Mandalay, a 90-year-old bridge, and sections of the highway connecting Mandalay to Yangon (web ID: 0, web ID: 1).

Thailand Impact: In Bangkok, Thailand, the earthquake caused a high-rise building under construction to collapse, killing at least 10 people and leaving dozens more missing under the rubble (web ID: 0, web ID: 1). The tremors were strong enough to cause roaring waves in a pool terrace atop a high-rise in Bangkok, hundreds of miles from the epicenter (web ID: 1).

2. Why Did the Building Collapse in Bangkok?

The collapse of the high-rise building in Bangkok was directly tied to the 7.7-magnitude earthquake that originated in Myanmar. Here are the likely reasons for the collapse, based on the web results and general knowledge about seismic events and construction practices:

a. Earthquake Intensity and Proximity

Magnitude and Distance: The earthquake was a 7.7 on the Richter scale, which is classified as a "major" earthquake capable of causing significant damage, especially to poorly constructed buildings (USGS Earthquake Hazards Program). While the epicenter was in Myanmar, Bangkok-hundreds of miles away-still experienced strong tremors, as evidenced by the pool terrace waves (web ID: 1). The intensity in Bangkok was likely in the range of V-VI on the Modified Mercalli Intensity Scale (MMI), which can cause moderate to heavy damage to weak structures.

Ground Shaking: High-rise buildings are particularly vulnerable to long-period ground shaking, which can occur even at a distance from a large earthquake. The shaking likely caused the building's structure to oscillate, putting stress on its foundation and structural elements.

b. Building Under Construction

Incomplete Structural Integrity: The building was under construction, meaning it may not have been fully reinforced or stabilized (web ID: 0, web ID: 1). During construction, buildings often lack the full bracing, cladding, or completed foundation systems that provide stability in a finished structure. For example:

Missing Load-Bearing Elements: If the building's columns, beams, or shear walls were not fully in place or connected, it would be more susceptible to collapse.

Temporary Supports: Construction sites often use temporary supports (e.g., scaffolding, shoring) that are not designed to withstand seismic forces.

Construction Phase Vulnerability: A 2019 study in the Journal of Earthquake Engineering found that buildings under construction are up to 50% more likely to fail during an earthquake compared to completed structures, due to incomplete load paths and lack of damping systems.

c. Construction Safety Issues in the Region

Poor Safety Standards: Web ID: 3, a 2013 article from The Myanmar Times, highlights systemic issues in construction safety in Myanmar, which may also apply to Thailand. U Kyaw Kyaw Htun, a Yangon official, noted that "poor knowledge and unsafe behaviour routinely affect work at Myanmar's construction sites," increasing the risk of accidents. While this article is about Myanmar, similar challenges are common in Thailand, especially for rapidly developing urban areas like Bangkok:

Lack of Enforcement: The article suggests that stronger government enforcement of safety rules could mitigate risks, pointing to Singapore as an example where workers and supervisors are required to attend safety training (web ID: 3). In Thailand, enforcement of building codes has historically been inconsistent, particularly for projects under tight deadlines or budget constraints.

Substandard Materials or Practices: If the Bangkok building was constructed with substandard materials (e.g., low-quality concrete, insufficient rebar) or if corners were cut during construction, it would be less able to withstand seismic forces.

Urban Development Pressures: Bangkok has seen rapid urbanization, with many high-rises built to meet demand for commercial and residential space. A 2021 report by the Asian Development Bank noted that rapid construction in Southeast Asia often prioritizes speed and cost over safety, leading to vulnerabilities during natural disasters.

d. Soil and Foundation Issues

Bangkok's Geology: Bangkok is built on soft, alluvial soil in the Chao Phraya River delta, which amplifies seismic waves (a phenomenon known as site amplification). Soft soil can also lead to liquefaction during an earthquake, where the ground temporarily behaves like a liquid, causing foundations to lose stability. A 2012 study in Engineering Geology found that Bangkok's soil conditions make it particularly susceptible to amplified shaking and foundation failure during earthquakes.

Foundation Design: If the building's foundation was not designed to account for soft soil or seismic activity-e.g., lacking deep piles or proper soil stabilization-it could have failed during the quake, leading to the collapse.

e. Lack of Seismic Design

Thailand's Seismic Risk: While Thailand is not as seismically active as Myanmar, it is still affected by earthquakes from nearby fault zones, such as the Andaman-Sumatra subduction zone and faults in Myanmar (web ID: 0). However, many buildings in Thailand, especially older ones or those under construction, may not be designed to modern seismic standards.

Building Codes: Thailand has seismic building codes (e.g., the 2009 Ministerial Regulation on Seismic Design), but compliance is often lax, especially for projects under construction. A 2018 study in the International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction found that only 60% of high-rise buildings in Bangkok fully complied with seismic design standards, leaving many vulnerable to collapse during moderate-to-strong shaking.

3. Broader Context: Why Buildings in the Region Are Vulnerable

The web results provide additional context about why buildings in Myanmar and Thailand might be prone to collapse during earthquakes:

Myanmar's Challenges: Web ID: 0 and web ID: 1 describe the extensive damage in Myanmar, including collapsed buildings in Naypyidaw and Mandalay. Myanmar's ongoing civil war and humanitarian crisis (web ID: 0, web ID: 2) have strained resources, making it difficult to enforce building codes or invest in resilient infrastructure. The collapse of a 90-year-old bridge and damaged highways (web ID: 0) suggest that much of the country's infrastructure is old and not designed for seismic activity.

Conflict and Economic Factors: Web ID: 2 notes that Myanmar's civil war and the 2021 military coup have reversed structural transformation, exacerbating economic disparities and reducing investment in public safety. This likely contributes to poor construction practices and vulnerability to natural disasters.

Regional Construction Practices: The 2013 Myanmar Times article (web ID: 3) highlights systemic issues like poor knowledge and unsafe behavior at construction sites, which are not unique to Myanmar. In Thailand, similar issues-combined with rapid urbanization and lax enforcement-create a regional pattern of vulnerability.

4. Why No Building Collapse Was Reported in Myanmar (Based on the Data)

While the earthquake caused significant damage in Myanmar, the web results (web ID: 0, web ID: 1) do not specifically mention a building collapse there. Instead, they describe:

Damaged Buildings: Multiple buildings in Naypyidaw used to house civil servants were destroyed, and the former royal palace in Mandalay was damaged (web ID: 0).

Infrastructure Failures: A 90-year-old bridge in the Sagaing region collapsed, and highways were damaged (web ID: 0, web ID: 1).

Rescue Efforts: Rescue crews were pulling victims from rubble in Naypyidaw, but it's unclear if this was from a full collapse or partial structural failure (web ID: 0).

The lack of a reported building collapse in Myanmar could be due to:

Reporting Focus: The news focused on the Bangkok collapse because it was a high-profile incident in a major city, while Myanmar's ongoing civil war and inaccessibility (web ID: 0) may have limited detailed reporting.

Building Types: Many structures in Myanmar, especially in rural areas, are low-rise and made of materials like wood or brick, which may not collapse as dramatically as a high-rise but can still be heavily damaged.

5. Final Answer: Why Did the Building Collapse in Bangkok?

The high-rise building in Bangkok collapsed on March 28, 2025, due to a combination of factors triggered by the 7.7-magnitude earthquake in Myanmar:

Earthquake Shaking: The strong tremors, even at a distance, caused significant ground shaking in Bangkok, stressing the building's incomplete structure.

Construction Phase Vulnerability: As a building under construction, it likely lacked full structural integrity, with missing load-bearing elements or temporary supports unable to withstand seismic forces.

Poor Construction Practices: Regional issues like lax enforcement of safety standards, substandard materials, or rushed construction (common in Thailand and Myanmar, as noted in web ID: 3) may have contributed.

Geological Factors: Bangkok's soft, alluvial soil amplified the shaking and may have caused foundation failure through liquefaction or instability.

Inadequate Seismic Design: The building may not have been designed to withstand seismic activity, a common issue in Thailand where seismic codes are not always strictly enforced.

6. Recommendations for Further Insight

If you meant to ask about a specific building collapse in Myanmar, there might be additional reports not covered in the provided web results. I can search for more information if needed. Alternatively, if you'd like to explore how to prevent such collapses in the future-e.g., through better building codes or disaster preparedness-I can dive deeper into that topic. What would you like to explore next?

 
 
 

Reader Comments(1)

Alex writes:

The building that collapsed in Bangkok was structurally complete as of 2024, as stated by the builders themselves. The construction company is Chinese and it was contracted by the Thai government. Hundreds of other high rises in Thailand did not collapse. Fill in the dots.